Historic House Listings

Idaho’s most expensive old house listing! Circa 1940. On one acre. $4,590,000

May 20, 2023

Welcome to Idaho’s most expensive old house listing! The home was built in 1940. It is located on 1.07 acres in McCall, Idaho. The home is situated on the shores of pristine Payette Lake. The home features vaulted ceilings, hardwood floors and a stone fireplace. I am going to assume the price of this is due to location. The property has a private dock, a shop and a bunkroom. One bedroom, one bathroom and 1,288 square feet. $4,590,000

Contact Mike Olson with Crawford Olson Real Estate Services

From the Zillow listing:


Rare opportunity on the pristine shores of the east arm of Payette Lake. Stunning 1.07-acre property boasts 100 feet of lake frontage–an idyllic setting with views and mature pine trees throughout. Scenic slope down to the water’s edge leaves plenty of room to build the home of your dreams, perfect for a daylight basement. Included is a charming cabin built in 1940, offering just under 800 square feet of cozy living space. There’s a spacious 40′ x 40′ shop, perfect for storing a pontoon boat, with a finished bedroom and other rooms. Upstairs, you’ll find 640 square feet of unfinished space used as a large bunk room. Enjoy beautiful western sunsets from the large private “T” dock. Storage in the boat house (with power) is right on the shore. This rare gem has been in the family since 1950. It’s an extraordinary chance to own a piece of history and create new memories for generations to come. Don’t miss this stunning piece of Idaho paradise.



Let them know you saw it on Old House Life!