Historic House Listings

Stagecoach Inn and Jesse James Tavern, Circa 1833 in Kentucky. $389,900

July 10, 2025

A lot of history with this house! Known as the Stagecoach Inn and Jesse James Tavern. It is said that visitors were John P. Gray, Jesse James, Andrew Jackson, Jenny Lind and Thomas Daily. The house was built in 1833. It is located on 1.22 acres in Guthrie, Kentucky. The house features a large porch, upper porch, wood floors, large fireplaces, crown moulding, spacious kitchen and a claw foot tub. There is 4,000 square feet of covered and uncovered porches and decks. There is a detached garage on the property. Four bedrooms, four bathrooms and 3,420 square feet. $389,900

Contact Jennifer Smotherman with Haley Auctions and Realty: 270-772-2879

From the Zillow listing:

 

Step into history with this exceptional opportunity to own the renowned Stagecoach Inn, a treasured property on the National Register of Historic Places. This historic gem has roots dating back to 1833 when it served as a vital stop for weary travelers and horses, including the notable John P. Gray. It is rumored that this historical inn has hosted famous patrons such as Andrew Jackson, Jenny Lind, Thomas Daily and even Jesse James! Nestled on a generous 1.22 +/- acre lot adorned with vibrant trees and beautiful flowers complete with a professional outside sprinkler system, the Stagecoach Inn boasts approximately 3,400 sq ft of inviting, comfortable living space on two floors. The property features an updated, modern kitchen, beautiful formal dining room that will accommodate a 12 seat table, comfortable living room, extra large foyer, four bedrooms, laundry room, and three and half beautiful updated bathrooms. The heart of this home is its rich history that you can feel in each room! The properties character can be enjoyed by admiring the beautiful woodwork, built in cabinets and closets, fireplaces and mantels, thick brick walls, original hardwood floors, clawfoot tub and unique doors and windows. Additionally, plantation shutters have been added on the first floor which adds character and privacy. Several pieces of the antique furnishings and decor are being offered with an acceptable offer. Outside, let your entertaining imagination begin with approximately 4,000 sq ft of covered and open deck space, enhanced with a barbeque area, lighting, fans, speakers, and a bar! Most of the outdoor furniture will remain with the property with an acceptable offer. There is also a 21×24 foot detached 2 car garage nearby as well. Conveniently located near the junction of Highways 181, 79 and 41, just west of Guthrie, Kentucky. This historic inn is a mere 10 minute drive to Clarksville and Interstate 24. Property is also located near Russellville, Hopkinsville, and Trenton, Kentucky and less than one hour from Nashville, TN! With a legacy spanning nearly 200 years, the Stagecoach Inn beautifully merges turn-of-the-century charm and history with modern day amenities. Whether you are dreaming of owning your own Bed and Breakfast, an AWESOME event venue or you want to make this property your personal, private residence, you need to take a close look in person at this one-of-a-kind property. It’s taken nearly 200 years to make this gem!

 

Let them know you saw it on Old House Life!